MOVING BEYOND
HUGGING AND WRESTLING

by YONATAN ARIEL,
ROBBIE GRINGRAS and
ESTI MOSKOVITZ-KALMAN

H ugging and Wrestling,” that liberating yet annoying catch-phrase, is all our fault. Here at MAKOM, a project of the Jewish Agency for Israel, we coined the phrase in 2005 and then promoted and promulgated it until it was adopted throughout the Jewish world.

Given the increasing complexity of both Jewish identity and Israeli society, we argued that a thought-free, instinctual, nonjudgmental relationship with Israel was neither healthy nor possible. Deliberately using a biblically Jewish concept, we pushed for an appreciation of “critique” as an expression of commitment.

Its time has passed. We’re moving on.

When we coined “hugging and wrestling,” we observed that Jews found themselves unable to voice their concerns about Israel’s behavior. They either saw themselves as traitors or were treated that way by others, and they could not find a space inside the community that allowed them to process their qualms about Israel in an intelligent and nuanced fashion.

Times have changed. Israel has since undergone a couple of wars and a couple of elections. New directions in Jewish identification have taken root; a new President has been elected; and technological advances mean that making one’s voice heard is no longer a problem. While nuance may still be lacking, no one now lacks a platform to wrestle with Israel.

We’ve begun to recognize fresh fault lines in the North American Jewish community’s relationship with Israel — fault lines that seem to be obscured by the ways “hugging and wrestling” has been interpreted.

IT’S NOT ONE OR THE OTHER

The slogan was conceived to set up a dichotomy: Either one critiques, or one praises. Where we wrote “and,” others heard “or.” Yet one of the reasons we’d chosen the image of hugging and wrestling was precisely its ambiguity.

We had aimed to suggest that life is complex; that our relationship with Israel is complex; and that while some critique can be an expression of support, some support might also contain a veiled critique.

We had heard of a well-respected organization that split its Israel programming team into two groups: One to plan programming that “wrestled” with Israel, and the other to plan programming that “hugged” Israel.

That wasn’t the idea.

IT DOESN’T SPLIT LEFT OR RIGHT

We also learned that people were happy to choose one or the other and put it down to politics. Apparently, if one is Orthodox and right-wing, then one must hug Israel and suspect all wrestlers. And if one is left-wing, then one cannot but wrestle and ridicule hugging. As if right-wingers had no critique of the disengagement from Gaza, or left-wingers had no appreciation of gay rights in Israel, or human beings had no innate need to both celebrate and challenge.

It seemed as if organizations had no problem agreeing with the complex demands of hugging and wrestling in theory, but in practice, people were becoming experts in only one or the other. Furthermore, elements of wrestling that occurred in the community were difficult to differentiate from plain enmity.

WRESTLING SHOULD BE UNCOMFORTABLE

We began to identify an interpretive pattern: No one had ever been in a real wrestling match.

When physically wrestling, the chances of losing one’s balance are very high. Yet we began to notice that Israel-wrestling, by contrast, entailed taking and holding an immovable stance. More detached referee than wrestler.

That wrestling risks losing one’s balance is what makes it educationally fertile. It requires not only that I critique Israel, but that I also allow Israel to critique me. So far, it seems that this dialogical challenge has been mostly avoided.

THE WAY FORWARD?

Perhaps the time has come to sketch out programming practicalities. At MAKOM, we work according to five key approaches, or androgogies (pedagogies for adults!).

1. ELEPHANTS IN THE ROOM

We must engage with what is burning inside the participants. If we marginalize the Israel-related issues that are of central concern to our participants, then we risk marginalizing Israel for them. This approach requires courage, honesty and optimism.

2. LOCAL VISTAS

There is no one size fits all. Every country and every community has its own cultural assumptions that influence the ways in which it may engage with Israel. These must be addressed and incorporated into the programming. Great programming for San Francisco may fail in Philadelphia and never pass muster in Toronto.

3. MULTI-VOCALITY

We do not believe in presenting both sides, we believe in presenting many sides. One’s understanding of issues will always be strengthened when placed in dialogue with different understandings. Yet the need to present a multi-vocal Israel is not just a matter of educational technique: It is a much truer representation of Israel’s complex nature.

4. A JEWISH CONVERSATION

When engaging with modern-day Israel, we must draw on and refer to wise Jews and their writings throughout the generations. In this way, we place Israel in the context of Jewish civilization and ensure that Israel will not be an optional add-on, but rather a central element of our Jewish lives.

5. EMPOWERING

Programming must point to opportunities for participants to make a difference. It can never be enough to learn intellectually about Israel’s flaws without being introduced to the organizations and people who strive to fix them.

It is this final androgogy that we see as crucial. Hugging and wrestling is a dynamic image, but one that doesn’t necessarily move you anywhere. As Forward columnist Jay Michaelson has noted, “It has become simply exhausting to maintain the ambivalence, the hugging and the wrestling, the endless fence sitting” (“How I’m Losing My Love For Israel,” the Forward, September 25, 2009). We suggest that successful engagement with Israel leads people to slip off the fence and work to better, not batter, Israel.

At the Delegitimization seminar that we ran for more than 100 leaders at the Global Jewish Forum of the Jewish Agency, we combined small-group text study, speakers from different political traditions and a specially written play that called on participants to address the censorship dangers of a belligerent campaign against delegitimization. The viewer’s guide that we produced in parallel with the release of the film Waltz with Bashir includes Bet Midrash study sheets, contemporary texts and open questions emerging from the characters in the film. “The Sermon Sparks,” produced for Rabbis wishing to increase the quality of their references to Israel from the pulpit, touches on sensitive topics together with references and links to outstanding Israeli NGOs that are working to better Israel.

It is this form of “responsible engagement,” with the emphasis on “response,” that we strive towards in our arts programming, our media, our workshops, our curricula and our consultations. ■


Yonatan Ariel is the Executive Director of MAKOM. Robbie Gringras is the Artist in Residence of MAKOM. Esti Moskovitz-Kalman is the Deputy Director and Director of Education with MAKOM. www.makomisrael.org.